lichess.org
Donate

Try to solve this sentence - Enigma machine

If you don't understand what it is, an enigma machine is to randomly mix a word or something into some letters that you can't understand. How powerful is it and how many days would it take to decrypt my random letters?
The sentence : QIOAE WHDAT MXPSE RZOIP VQVKQ KLBFO FORQU ZEFFL LOXCT BIBIX WHURM YJ
Good luck solving!
I hope you didn't use the actual Enigma machine from WW2 (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enigma_machine#Breaking_Enigma). If so this encryption would be extremely hard to break without owning an Enigma machine yourself and knowing the key (the correct rotor positions).

The machine had 158,962,555,217,826,360,000 different settings (≈159 quintillion). That's too many to break by hand if all we're given is such a short message.
I believe there are some enigma emulators online. Haven't tried one though.
I believe the actual Enigma machine of the Germans in WW2 at first involved a three rotor system eventually upgraded to five rotors.It may never have been broken except for the capture of an actual machine and logbooks from a German submarine.It was really rather ingenious based upon the initial settings and was probably unbreakable without that information.Do you think your message is susceptible to frequency analysis or should I not waste my time?
@FC-in-the-UK said in #6:
> I believe there are some enigma emulators online. Haven't tried one though.
Yes, I used one of them.
And I don't hope that there are many replies like this!
One hint for @Thalassokrator and others: Decrypting it doesn't use much time.
Here's the link I used for the sentence: www.101computing.net/enigma-machine-emulator/
But this sentence, I mixed the rotors making it very hard to decrypt it.
If Alan Turing is still alive he would had a hard time solving this :)(I'm good at history)
Sentence 2:
JECLK FVLUG MRAZB UNNSK YMESL VZSLU PFZDB KMYTB WBTOA FPACP CMXSS SBESE CAKOD JUFGS AHJDG PPVFR VXOHB VIGWY XLOHJ MDQTI XQNJG MVQRU PGGTG NWCJ
@chessforeverything said in #9:
> One hint for at Thalassokrator and others: Decrypting it doesn't use much time.
> Here's the link I used for the sentence: www.101computing.net/enigma-machine-emulator/
> But this sentence, I mixed the rotors making it very hard to decrypt it.
> If Alan Turing is still alive he would had a hard time solving this :)(I'm good at history)

It's cool that you're interested in cryptography and history! :-)
Alan Turing is one of the most underrated geniuses of the 20th century. I recommend the movie "The Imitation Game", which gives a beautifully dramatised account of parts of his life. I wouldn't be able to type this (on a modern computer/phone) right now, if it hadn't been for him (and others of course). Unfortunately, I'm no Alan Turing.

And you're right, even he would have a hard time breaking your ciphers.
It doesn't really help at all that you posted the Enigma emulator that you used. Any good cryptography scheme should satisfy a very important condition:

"Neither knowledge of the key nor of the process of encryption shall be sufficient (individually) to break the encryption."

Enigma satisfies this standard to a high degree. The machine itself (without the key) is (pretty much) useless for decrypting messages known to have been encrypted by Enigma. And the key itself (without knowing that the message was encrypted by an Enigma machine) is useless as well.
Both the process of encryption and the key must be known simultaneously to decipher a message.

That's why the Website alone doesn't help me at all. It is a (emulated) Enigma machine, but it's (nearly) useless without knowledge of the key (the correct rotor positions).

There's a slight caveat in what I just said: Obtaining a real Enigma machine from a sinking submarine was indeed a crucial part in the cryptanalysis of Enigma in WW2. It allowed the British to build an electromechanical device known as "Bombe" (designed by Alan Turing), which ultimately could be used to decipher some (not all) Enigma messages (greatly aiding the allies in the war). It should also be noted that many of the advances of the British in breaking the Enigma were based on knowledge shared with them by Polish cryptanalysts (Marian Rejewski among them) who had began work on Enigma at a much earlier time and had had some breakthroughs. Their outstanding work shouldn't be forgotten.

Still, breaking Enigma took years of work by some of the world's most talented cryptanalysts at the time! So I don't think I'd stand a chance.

Especially because Alan Turing et al. had tons of encrypted Enigma messages to work with (hundreds every day). While I only have two very short ones. In general, the shorter the encrypted message, the harder it is to decrypt (because statistical approaches only become powerful for long messages).

Addendum:

For anyone who loves cryptography, this one is actually solvable (it's relatively easy). I'll give you some hints to guide you:
- It's a substitution cipher
- It uses a keyword
- The keyword is short, so look out for repeating strings in the cipher-text
- Both the keyword and the plaintext are in English (without spelling-mistakes)

"E ENXJ GBA PW GXWDRR EV GNA UVJZTR IKCEYA, QPGNCF, YK BUGP BUK SIIKO
UNE JWG CAQTN ZWJT UWHX SQAMO QS EKC TU PWB RKE,
NTZ AB ZDIG ZDM FAJ EVRH VBZ OKBXYP LUQZ JOJOF OB GBA CW GUK PVMD.
AGGU JRZSMRT XWGN. E WEJAZ LUQ VBZ PW YUKS NZ XWBZAA,
BX DMYOYM, BX PPR JNIJT OEBXZ WS UNQBT.
SQGN IM YKWLVTC, AROVM GNA ENE!" DM UGJLF URME GP BUK OIZK PQZK PPR XQTRY KN SRUQAM
WVQ LEBF ZDM HTGVBCJ EVTCA BT DQF YDWHRZMEY.
XMGCAMA ZDM JUNS NTZ ENXJQAMO BUK KTQ IDMRQO OEKS ERZ,
WVQ NEA SGPPRXHG UGJLF ZNMZHHMQ.

For ease of analysis the same text without punctuation (and with spaces every 5 letters):
EENXJ GBAPW GXWDR REVGN AUVJZ TRIKC EYAQP GNCFY KBUGP BUKSI IKOUN EJWGC AQTNZ WJTUW HXSQA MOQSE KCTUP WBRKE NTZAB ZDIGZ DMFAJ EVRHV BZOKB XYPLU QZJOJ OFOBG BACWG UKPVM DAGGU JRZSM RTXWG NEWEJ AZLUQ VBZPW YUKSN ZXWBZ AABXD MYOYM BXPPR JNIJT OEBXZ WSUNQ BTSQG NIMYK WLVTC AROVM GNAEN EDMUG JLFUR MEGPB UKOIZ KPQZK PPRXQ TRYKN SRUQA MWVQL EBFZD MHTGV BCJEV TCABT DQFYD WHRZM EYXMG CAMAZ DMJUN SNTZE NXJQA MOBUK KTQID MRQOO EKSER ZWVQN EASGP PRXHG UGJLF ZNMZH HMQ

Allowed resources that might make your life easier:
http://mathcenter.oxford.emory.edu/site/math125/englishLetterFreqs/

www.boxentriq.com/code-breaking/frequency-analysis

www.boxentriq.com/code-breaking/caesar-cipher

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.